PSX Stocks vs. Mutual Funds

Many new investors ask: should I pick my own stocks, or let a fund manager do it? The honest answer is that it depends on your time, your temperament and the fees you pay. This page puts real numbers on each side.

How a mutual fund works in Pakistan

A fund pools money from many investors and buys a basket of securities. You own units, priced at the fund's net asset value (NAV), which is recalculated every day. Funds are run by asset management companies (AMCs) and regulated by the SECP. The industry body, MUFAP, publishes every fund's daily NAV, returns and expense ratio, so you can compare funds on one site.

This page compares equity funds with direct stock investing, because that is the real choice for someone who wants stock-market returns.

Fees: what a fund actually costs

A fund's total expense ratio (TER) is the percentage of the fund's assets taken each year to cover management, selling and marketing, and other costs. According to MUFAP's expense-ratio data for March 2026, equity funds charged roughly 3.4% to 5.1%:

Expense ratios change every month and differ by fund. Check MUFAP for the current figure of any fund before you invest.

The returns MUFAP quotes for a fund are already net of these costs. The practical point is this: to leave you better off than simply owning the same shares, the fund manager has to beat the market by roughly the expense ratio every year. Over a decade, a 4% annual cost is large. If the shares in a fund return 15% a year before costs, Rs. 1,000,000 grows to about Rs. 4.05 million over 10 years. After a 4% annual cost (11% net), it grows to about Rs. 2.84 million, a difference of about Rs. 1.2 million. This is an illustration of the arithmetic, not a forecast of any fund's return.

Direct investing has its own costs: brokerage commission on each trade, CDC and other charges, and tax. See tax on PSX trading and dividends. These are normally a fraction of a percent per trade, much lower than a fund's yearly charge for someone who trades rarely.

Risk and diversification: real PSX examples

A fund holds dozens of companies, so one company's bad year hurts less. To see what that means in practice, here is how three large stocks from different sectors did over the five years from 30 June 2021 to 30 June 2026, using our own daily price history:

*Annualized volatility of daily price changes. Prices only, so dividends are excluded and returns are understated, especially for dividend payers like FFC and OGDC. The mix assumes equal weights, rebalanced daily, and is hypothetical. The last five years were unusually strong for PSX; past performance does not predict the future. Try your own combination in the Portfolio Risk & Return tool.

Notice that the three-stock mix swung less than each stock on its own (25% against 29-37%) and avoided HBL's 53% fall. That is diversification, and a fund gives it to you automatically with many more stocks. If you hold only one or two shares, you carry that company's full risk.

Shariah-compliant options

Several AMCs run Shariah-compliant equity funds, such as Al Meezan Mutual Fund in the table above, which hold only shares passing a Shariah screen. If you invest directly, you can build the same kind of portfolio from Shariah-compliant stocks. See Islamic stock investing in Pakistan.

How to choose a fund

1. Match the type to your goal. Money for under 3 years belongs in a money market or income fund (or a deposit), not an equity fund.
2. Check the expense ratio and prefer the lower one among similar funds.
3. Compare long-term returns to the KSE-100 over 3, 5 and 10 years, net of fees. A fund that cannot beat the index after costs is just an expensive index.
4. Read the fund's fact sheet for its top holdings, sector mix, and any sales load or redemption charges.
5. Understand the tax on fund income and gains, which differs from tax on shares and changes with each budget.

A simple way to start

Keep a diversified fund as your core holding and use a small portion of your money for individual stocks you have researched. Before using real money for the stock part, practice with the free Rs. 10 lakh virtual portfolio here, then compare your results with the market.

Sources: MUFAP expense-ratio data (March 2026); Pak Stock Exchange daily closing prices. For education only, not investment advice. Fund figures and rules change; confirm them with the fund's documents before investing.

← Back to Resource Hub